| Year | Winning Club | Team Average | Team Score | Top Gun | 
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Youngstown Country Club | 47 | 1163 | B. Benyo - 239 | 
| 2023 | Youngstown Country Club | 45.76 | 1175 | B. Benyo - 242 | 
| 2022 | Hunting Valley | 46.8 | 1170 | H. Vavrik - 238 | 
| 2021 | Hunting Valley | 47.2 | 943 | P. Taylor, Jr. - 190 | 
| 2020 | Country Club | 46.8 | 935 | B. Wesorick - 196 | 
| 2019 | Country Club | 45.9 | 917 | P. Taylor, Jr. - 189 | 
| 2018 | Mentor Harbor | 46.7 | 933 | P. Taylor, Jr - 194 | 
| 2017 | Hunting Valley | 46.4 | 927 | P. Taylor, Jr. - 197 | 
| 2016 | Country Club | 46.6 | 929 | S. Anderson - 192 | 
| 2015 | Hunting Valley | 45.4 | 907 | P. Taylor, Jr.- 189 | 
| 2014 | Hunting Valley | 45.2 | 904 | S. Anderson - 191 | 
| 2013 | Hunting Valley | 46.4 | 927 | S. Anderson - 192 | 
| 2012 | Country Club | 44.5 | 890 | B. Buescher - 184 | 
| 2011 | Hunting Valley | 46.6 | 932 | S. Bolton - 188 | 
| 2010 | Hunting Valley | 46.5 | 930 | B. Buescher - 194 | 
| 2009 | Hunting Valley | 47.4 | 948 | J. Koch - 194 | 
| 2008 | Hunting Valley | 46.6 | 1166 | J. Moroscak - 238 | 
| 2007 | Hunting Valley | 47.9 | 1199 | D. DiPalma -242 | 
| 2006 | Hunting Valley | 46.7 | 1167 | P. Jagnow - 240 | 
| 2005 | Hunting Valley | 47.0 | 1175 | H. Vavrik - 244 | 
| 2004 | Hunting Valley | 47.8 | 1186 | T. Commes - 245 | 
| 2003 | Hunting Valley | 47.5 | 1196 | G. Bruhn - 244 | 
| 2002 | Hunting Valley | 47.1 | 1178 | J. Haugh - 248 | 
| 2001 | Hunting Valley | 46.8 | 1170 | P. Jagnow - 242 | 
| 2000 | Hunting Valley | 48.6 | 1215 | D.Brugh/J.Haugh - 248 | 
| 1999 | Mentor Harbor | 47.5 | 1188 | J. Haugh - 247 | 
| 1998 | Mentor Harbor | 48.3 | 1208 | J. Haugh - 244 | 
| 1997 | Hunting Valley | 48.2 | 1206 | J. Haugh - 245 | 
| 1996 | Hunting Valley | 48.6 | 1216 | T. Commes - 244 | 
| 1995 | Hunting Valley | 48.7 | 1218 | G. Baum - 245 | 
| 1994 | Hunting Valley | 48.6 | 1214 | G. Baum - 245 | 
| 1993 | Hunting Valley | 48.92 | 1223 | P. Taylor, Sr. - 246 | 
| 1992 | Hunting Valley | 48.8 | 1221 | B. Downie - 246 | 
| 1991 | Hawthorne Valley | 48.6 | 973 | B. Downie - 198 | 
| 1990 | Hunting Valley | 48.8 | 975 | T. Commes - 196 | 
| 1989 | Hunting Valley | 48.7 | 1218 | B. Downie - 247 | 
| 1988 | Mentor Harbor | 48.8 | 1220 | T. Barton - 245 | 
| 1987 | Mentor Harbor | 48.8 | 1220 | B. Downie - 246 | 
| 1986 | Mentor Harbor | 48.0 | 1199 | B. Downie - 246 | 
| 1985 | Hawthorne Valley | 47.6 | 1190 | J. Prusa - 244 | 
| 1984 | Mentor Harbor | 48.1 | 1202 | Bill Downie - 243 | 
| 1983 | Hunting Valley | 48.6 | 972 | B. Mulby/J. Prusa - 196 | 
| 1982 | Hawthorne Valley | 48.1 | 963 | H. Zimmerman - 197 | 
| 1981 | Hawthorne Valley | 47.5 | 712 | Bill Downie - 147 | 
| 1980 | Country Club | 46.2 | 925 | J. Donahey - 196 | 
| 1979 | Hunting Valley | 47.5 | 949 | R. Majer/H. Rowen - 192 | 
| 1978 | Hunting Valley | 47.5 | 941 | Bill Downie - 194 | 
| 1977 | Hunting Valley | 46.4 | 928 | unknown | 
| 1976 | Hunting Valley | 47.1 | 942 | unknown | 
| 1975 | Hunting Valley | 47 | 939 | unknown | 
| 1974 | Hunting Valley | 47.3 | 946 | Bill Downie - 192 | 
| 1973 | Hunting Valley | 47.6 | 951 | J. Donahey - 194 | 
| 1972 | Hunting Valley | 46.9 | 938 | A. Kundtz - 192 | 
| 1971 | Hunting Valley | 46.4 | 928 | J. Donahey - 193 | 
| 1970 | Hunting Valley | 47.5 | 950 | Agnes Thomas/J. Donahey - 193 | 
| 1969 | Hunting Valley | 47.8 | 956 | Bill France/Bill Downie - 192 | 
| 1968 | Country Club | 46.2 | 925 | J. Donahey - 193 | 
| 1967 | Hunting Valley | new scoring system | 174 | Bill France/Bill Downie - 190 | 
| 1966 | Hunting Valley | 48.5 | 970 | Bob Snyder - 196 | 
| 1965 | Hunting Valley | 45.0 | 705 | C. Harris - 145 | 
| 1964 | Hunting Valley | 48.2 | 964 | Bill France - 195 | 
| 1963 | Hunting Valley | 48.2 | 964 | Bill France - 198*** | 
| 1962 | Hunting Valley | 48.3 | 966 | Bill France - 198*** | 
| 1961 | Hunting Valley | 48.3 | 966 | Bill France/Jack Donahey/Jake Wilson - 195 | 
| 1960 | Hunting Valley | 48.95** | 979 | Bill France - 198* | 
| 1959 | Country Club | 46.7 | 933 | unknown | 
| 1958 | Country Club | 47.7 | 942 | J. Donahey - 194 | 
| 1957 | Country Club | 45.6 | 912 | unknown | 
| 1956 | Hunting Valley | 45.2 | 903 | unknown | 
| 1955 | Hunting Valley | 46.0 | 920 | George Dean - 193 | 
| 1954 | Hunting Valley | 44.7 | 671 | unknown | 
| 1953 | Mentor Harbor | 43.1 | 647 | unknown | 
| 1952 | Mentor Harbor | 44.8 | 448 | unknown |